Lounge and Entertainment >> Partisan Politics and Controversy >> What does "Supporting the Troops" mean to you?
What does "Supporting the Troops" mean to you?
| back to top |
Posted 2 months ago So, what does supporting the troops mean to you? No descriptions or explanations, I'm leaving this wide open, as it should be. Please be respectful of others when replying, thank you. |
|
back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago It's a really hard question to answer, so I'm going to kinda sidetrack a little.
When people talk about supporting the troops in a political context these days, it generally is referencing the deployments in the middle east. Within that discussion, most generally the term is used as an attack on people who don't support the war on terror, equating "not supporting the war" with "not supporting the troops."
That's very, very wrong in my view. I personally do not suppor the war in Iraq. However, I support the troops. This is a very easy position to intentionally misinterpret, as has been done on many occasions by supporters of the war, so lets break it down until it is clear:
I do not support the troops being in Iraq. However, I do support the troops in Iraq. The only difference between the two statements is the word "being," but it is VERY important. I do not support the troops being there, but as long as they ARE there I support them.
The key to my view is that it is not the troops' fault they are there. It is President Bush's fault. Soldiers go where they are told. Our armed forces deserve the best we can give them no matter WHAT retarded orders our President gives them. They deserve the best equipment, training, and support we can give them. They do NOT deserve to be sent in undermanned, without proper armor, and without proper planning simply because there isn't enough support to send them in properly. If we can't support the troops the way they deserve, they should never have been sent at all. The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter."
"Democracy is the worst form of government except for all those others that have been tried."
|
| back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago thanks for all the support it doese not go unoticed thank you
from the soldier in IRAQ |
|
back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago I have no problem with people voicing their opinion against the war, or any war. My problem is when they put down the same people who are protecting their right to voice their opinion. If you're gonna be a bear....be a grizzly... |
| back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago I agree scooby I agree |
|
back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago People are under the assumption that it's the warrior who wants the war. If you're gonna be a bear....be a grizzly... |
| back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago ScoobyDoo says ...
Could it be due to some of our Heros volunteering? I had a cousin wh was KIA in Vietnam. I wanted to get to know more on who he was. i had found out from someone who worked side by side with him (both being an RTO). I was told that my cousin was ferless and that he was one who could always be counted on. He did his plus helped others with their dutys. He even volunteered for a dangerous nigth watch which i was told NOONE did. My cousin also met a man in bootcamp that also was Airborne. They became close buds and planned on getting together after the war. This bud is now an auithor and has mentioned my cousin in one of his books Eye of the Eagle. How do i support or Troops? I pass on those chain emails that i normally wont. If i see a miltary persn in public i walk up and just say Thank You. (I remember the 1st guy i id that too and the look on his fce was priceless.) I dont think anyone has ever Thanked Him cause i seen the shock and appreciation in his eyes. I prayer for our soldiers and I'm not a very religious person but they may be so i prayer to their God.(Not an Atheist) I try to donate regularly to the disalbed Vets and any other that has to do with helping our soldiers. So for those who are here that were/are or will be in our military THANK YOU!
I'm not short I'm Fun size! |
| back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago Supporting them means that no matter who put them wherever they are (as we have troops throughout the world and not just in Iraq and Afghanistan) is standing up for them. Those people are out there fighting or stationed in these places because they were sent, but we have people in service because they elected to be there. There's not one person among them that was drafted. There are plenty of site on the internet where you can send a message, maybe there's someone in churches throughout the country who knows someone who is out there. Whether or not I agree with President Bush or not, these people are out there doing what they consider is their job/duty. They didn't have to do it, but the fact is that they decided to join. Some are in Turkey, Japan, Afghanistan, Korea, Iraq and who knows where else. I salute them. Some are staying in service, some are leaving after their tour of duty. Some people are like my boss' son elected to go back to Iraq. I'm sure there are others out there that we don't know about who are risking their lives. I ask God to watch them and keep them safe. I cover them in prayer. Send cards even though they don't know you, they need to know that someone out there cares. |
| back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago Nice post peacebe |
| back to top |
| Posted 2 months ago Thanks. I want these people to come back thinking that they did something good. They accomplished something. I remember all too well the welcome that people received after coming back from Vietnam. These people are out there with their lives on the line. Some even take their own life by using their own body to shield a grenade so that others may live. I love our troops out there wherever they are stationed doing whatever they are told. They may not have a ticker tape parade when they get home, but the love of family and friends mean so much more and just being there when they go through those memories after they get back home. It was hard to adjust back during the days of WWII and it's no different now. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Throughout the history of the United States it citizens, both men and women, have heard the call when our nation's survival and the freedoms enshrined in the constitution and other founding documents of our country have been threatened. I come from a family with a long tradition of military service. My direct ancestors came over on the Mayflower and from that day we have served this nation in its times of need. The Mayflower Compact was one of the seminal documents that helped give rise to this nation of freemen and women. In defense of the principles of that compact, and the ensuing founding documents of this nation, my family and its members, old and new imigrants, have fought in every war this nation has been involved in. From the battlefields of the revolution, the civil war, WWI, WWII, Korea, Vietnam, the Cold War, Desert Storm, Iraqi Freedom and the Global War on terror, members of my family have walked, shed blood and died on these fields. We did so out of love of this nation and for the principles enshrined in those historic documents that gave rise to this nation of free men and women. After each war our family members came home, those who did not pay the ultimate price and could not be found, and reentered civil society. All bore scars both physical and psychological from those wars. In the days before we as a nation found the goodness to aid our veterans, they did without federal assistance. Despite all of this, each succeding generation of my family sent forth its members when asked by this nation. We did not expect payment for our pain and suffering but rather took pride that we helped preserve this bastion of hope and freedom for all mankind. I have, in my study, my great great great grandfather's pension papers from the civil war. He fought on foot throughout the war and walked his way across its great battlefields to watch Lee surrender. When he came home and could not work his farm, his family forced him to put in for a civil war pension. Wounded three times on the battlefields of the civil, he patched up and sent to the front again and again from makeshift field hospitals. He survived the rigors of those blood stained battlefields and lived to watch the end to our bloodiest war. I note with some sadness that upon reviewing his pension papers that the federal government paid more to bury him then it paid him in pension monies. I also recall my grandfather who served in WWII and fought his way accross France to the outskirts of Berlin and the Elb river. He was an artillery man. He loved to sit on the porch during thunderstorms because it reminded him of the thunder of the guns. He also cried in his sleep because of what he saw as the war ended and the death camps were uncovered. He had the unfortunate experience of visiting Bergen Belson after its liberation by the UK in WWII. Of all the death he saw, both during the Battle of the Bulge and subsequent campaigns, he was haunted until his death by the sights he saw there. He lived a long time and died in a VA hospital. Like my ancestor from the civil war, the government paid more to bury him then to care for him while he was alive. Despite this he was forever proud of his service and died knowing he had faced the forces of darkness on the battlefields of Europe and seen the forces of evil vanquished. For me when I hear the term supporting our troops I think of my family and the its efforts to heal those of its members scared by war. What we must remember with regards to this subject is that while at the end of the day we can debate and disagree with those that sent our men and women to war, they themselves went because of their love of this nation and the freedoms it bestowed upon them. Given this it is our obligation to support them when they return home and help them reenter our society. Aiding those who bear the scars of war, and caring for those families whose loved ones will never return home, is a moral obligation that we must bear if we are to continue to survive as a free people. As for me. I, and my wife, have too, served this nation in the flaming crucible of war or the icy embrace of the Cold War. We both know war's horrors well. Like many of my ancestors I too carry scars and memories that will never fade. Like them I have with the aid of my family, reentered civil society and put down the weapons of war. From time to time I hear echoes as did many other members of my family of old battlefields in far off lands and the thunder of the guns which oddley seem to call me back to them on occasion. Both I and my wife will live our lives out as common folk earning our living from our labor and do not expect much from the federal government. I expect, like most other members of our family, that the government will pay more to bury us than to care for us while we live. However, despite this we stand proud of our service and will, when the time comes, pass with the knowledge that we too faced the forces of darkness. When we stood there in Germany and watched the Berlin Wall fall, knew that we had helped do our part to defeat the forces of evil facing our generation. In us the cycle that has repeated itself from generation to generations once again manefested itself. Each generation must face its own forces of darkness, some here at home and some in far off lands under foreign skys. When called our American families send forth their members to face these evil legions. We do so because we know few other people have the courage or willingness to pay the price to defeat such forces. In these current wars, our family members fight a foe unlike those we have faced before. One who abides by no rules and seeks to kill the innocent. Due to the nature of this type of conflict many come home with scars that will be a long time fading. As in each cycle will come the time for us to open or hearts to these men and women and aid them in reentering civil society. I hope and pray that this time, we will provide them services equal to the task and demands we asked them to accomplish and endure. May God keep and protect this nation of the people by the people for the people.
|
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago There have been a lot of mistakes and definite denials of helping the vets to get back on their feet or overcoming their physical, mental, or emotional problems. There's the people that fought in Vietnam and yet the doctors and others who said Agent Orange did not cause the problems that it did. How about those problems after WWII when some men who came back had problems getting loans? Then there are the troops with psychological problems who had to do what they were told as kids -- actually killing many people. As you pointed out that this happens throughout history, unfortunately. Don't forget that those people who had their limbs cut off during the Civil War mostly died from infection. If you look long and hard enough you can always find something wrong with the government. Some things have to change and really need to change. Let's look long and hard enough to see how we can really support the troops. Vets do need better treatment when they come back with problems or they come back only to find that someone took their job away from them. Perhaps they are looking for something else because they have a family now whereas they before they left they didn't have a family. Let's change what needs to be changed, but let's find better ways of doing it than just putting a bandage on it. What suggestions do you have? Let's have our troops who elected to enter service, come back with the knowledge that their country loves them. I salute those who are in military service. What happened when those Vietnam vets came back is something that shouldn't be repeated. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago The support is what gets us through these long deployements I am on my 15 month rotation and will be returning back to germany at the end of NOV early december and then sent out to FT Stewart and the 3rd Infantry Division and will most likley return sometime next year to either IRAQ or Afghanisstan. But that is what war is like you come home to train to go back out again. Thank you for all the support |
|
back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Fishingguy: My great great great grandfather faught at Gettysburg. My family name in on the Pa monument. If you're gonna be a bear....be a grizzly... |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago ScoobyDoo, I've been to that monument in Gettysburg. That is a huge memorial to those who died in battle. Very brave. Especially then where the bullets caused as much damage if not more. I've seen pictures of what it looked like after some got shot with those miniballs. Not a pretty sight. Your great, great, great grandfather must have really been someone whom his family could have been proud of. Perhaps he knew the 72 year ol man from town with his musket fighting along with the troops. I think that must be the biggest monument there. I still get moved when I read "Fourscore and seven years ago ..." at the Lincoln monument at the cemetary. God bless everyone who fights for this country. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago yeah peacebe I those where nasty rounds and alot of people had to get amputated beucase they were so hard to remove |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago In terms of supporting the troops returning from the wars, some specific recomendations I have are as follows: 1. Expanded medical coverage for those suffering from PTSD induced psychological trauma. In specfic veterans suffering from PTSD need more access to psychological services from the civilian sector. The VA's VET centers are good but at present do not have the resources to adequately meet the needs of all service members. Their services should be supplemented by funding for treatment by civilian providers for those that, for what ever reason, can not have their needs met at the VET Center or VA Hospital. 2. Development of alternative sentencing programs for veterans suffering from PTSD induced pyschological disorders who commit crimes. This would not excuse their behavior but open a door for mandated treatment rather than compounding the problem by putting them in a worse situation by comiting them to prison. 3. Expansion of the VA's adaptive housing program for disabled veteran's and increasing the amount of money allocated for the program. This would be coupled to increased payments for service connected disabilities. 4. Increasing the ease of hiring disabled veterans by making it a priority within the federal government to actively target such people for open positions. 5. Expanding the VOCREHAB program to include online universities greatly assisting disabled veterans in acquiring certifications and degrees in preparation for post military careers. I offer the above as some examples of things that could be done to assist veterans with the transition back to civilian life. I have focused on disabled veterans as they are the ones most in need, but recognize that all veterans need assistance. For those who have put their lives on the line for us we owe then much. For ScoobyDoo. Gettysburg was the turning point in the war. As such it was a defining moment in American history. Each of us that had ancestors who fought in that war should study what exactly those soldiers were called upon to do. When I read my ancestor's story as recorded in his civil war pension application I was taken aback by the suffering he went through. It made much of my own pains as a result of military service pale in comparison. For those that paid the ultimate price we owe a debt beyond that which material wealth can bestow. As Lincoln said, that battlefield is holy ground. What I tried to convey in my previous posting is that each generation of Americans are faced with their own unique enemy of darkness. This enemy comes in many forms and is fought in many places including court rooms and in the press as well as on the battlefield. What our ancestors have shown us is that somethings are worth dying for or giving up your material possessions for. As stated in the inspired words of our Declaration of Independence, "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness. That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed". For these words, and the others that form the basis of our society, many have given up their lives, property and reputations so that these words and what they gave rise to, could never be undone. I also wish to recognize the fact that it was not just our ancestors who fought in our long ago wars that fought and died for these words but also wave after wave of imigrants from all lands. Men and women who upon their arrival in this country, volunteered to fight for it in WWI, WWII, Korea, Vietnam, Grenada, and all the other conflicts. Some came straight off the boats and shortly there after got back on the troop ships destined for a place in history. America is an inclusive nation by its nature and as such stands alone among the great nations of this earth. May God Keep and Bless the United States of America |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Those miniballs put huge holes in people. They didn't sterilize their equipment, not did they really have the time to do so even if they had the know how. That's why many people throughout the war died, not from the bullets, but from the infection which set in. I salute everyone who goes out there and is stationed wherever they may go. There is far to go to fix what the vets need once returning home, but really admire those who go back again. The church secretary's son signed up to go back to Iraq. There are those who also, like the Japanese and the Germans who fought for the US' side during WWI an WWII. It wasn't easy for them as they had to fight discrimination as well as the enemy. God bless America and all those out there who put their lives on the line for us and for their fellow soldiers as well. This includes the marines, navy, and air force. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Thanks PEACEBE |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago You're welcome! I salute every single person out there protecting not our nation, but those of other nations. Don't know what we would do without our "warriors" and that also includes the chaplains out there. You're not out there playing a game of Tiddly Winks. (Do you even have time to do that even if you wanted to?) It's about time more people told you what a fantastic job you are doing. There's a pin that I wear from time to time -- American/Israel pin. I love both countries. Thank you so much for what you do! |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago that is awsome we really do not have that much time out here we work 12-16 hour days and then go to sleep so it is long and tiring |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago And this is not like a sports game where you can take a player out temporarily and put someone else in to either play the rest of the game or just part of the game. This isn't a game. This is real. Not only that, but you're there because you signed up. You weren't drafted. There are medics out there who are probably taking care of patients at a faster rate than if they were a doctor or physician's assistant. You can't make an appointment to be seen. You may be able to be "squeezed in" during periods of low times. Oh, wait, don't you have to be aware at all times, what am I thinking?! What low times? You all are doing the best job that you can. May God be with you and keep your paths straight so that you can do the job the best way that you can do. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago I think the two most important ways to support the troops are as follows: 1. Keeping them out of harm's way unless absolutely necessary and having the humility to take them out of harm's way when putting them there in the first place might have been wrong. 2. Making sure they receive the best healthcare, benefits and educational opportunities possible and that they are rewarded for their service. This means keeping the wounded in clean hospitals, paying for surgeries for combat injuries and providing the highest level of educational support possible. No matter your position on the war in Iraq, we have to admit that our country has failed in doing this over the last 5 years. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Keeping hospitals clean are tough for people in any hospital, whether VA or regular. At age 83, a doctor asked him where he wanted to have heart surgery. He had it and entered staph. What happened afterwards was due to the staph infection. What does "in harms way" mean? Who decides that? I don't know too much about the American Revolution, but there were riots during the Civil War because of the draft even then. That's when our country was definitely divided. There are soldiers in Iraq, Africa, Afghanistan, Turkey, North/South Korea, Japan, and who knows where else. I agree that they should have better benefits and when someone comes back from a war where they used napalm, for instance, they should look into it rather than saying it's all in your head. They should be able to come home knowing that their country loves them. Emotional support means so much to someone away from home. A card, an e-mail, anything that keeps people connected not only with loved ones, but those that don't them. Last year the movie, The Christmas Card came out, is what I'm talking about. All the relationship with the family just started with someone sending a homemade Christmas Card out to a soldier. In the movie, the soldier kept going because of the card which he kept in his back pocket and read during his private times. As a child, the school teacher had all of us write "cards" to soldiers out there. Some we heard back from, others we never heard from. Some "cards" got lost. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago There's a song by Steven Curtis Chapman called That's What We're Fighting for. If you get a chance to hear it, please do so. It's about a man who's fighting in the desert and thinks about his little girl and his wife. They pray themselves to sleep at night and his wife tells their daughter that everything's going to be alright. The soldier knows that everyone has their own opinion about whether what he and the other soldiers are doing is good or bad. He sees children as he passes a playground and they look up and smile and wave at him and the others with him. He notes that there is something in the children's eyes -- the biggest change. He remembers about other people's opinions as to why the soldiers are over there, but when he closes his eyes, he sees his little girl and her mother, praying themselves to sleep. Dreaming of the day when he comes back home. Because this is what he's fighting for. This night he prays himself to sleep and dream about the time when he does come home to his family. Then he awakens back to what he's fighting for. This is what he's fighting for. This beautiful song was playing and couldn't help but share it. To every member of the armed services serving or have served, my prayers go out to you. To those who never reached home but are in a better place, prayers go to your family and friends. May God's love shine over you and protect you from harm. May you see it, but never reach you. Let Him make your paths straight and smooth. God loves you and I love you. Thank you so much. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Excellent post, peacebe! I have to give kudos to SnoopysPal concerning thanking servicemembers for their service. I know I honestly don't know how to respond either. "Your welcome" doesn't seem to suffice, especially when we have experienced situations that drive home our own reasons for serving that many people can't or decide not to try to understand. I am honestly taken back someone took the time to thank me for mine or someone else's service. In some ways I don't feel deserving of the thanks when I'm not actually in the battle or actively supporting the fight (been in both situations). I tend to believe those currently out in the fight deserve our utmost thanks. It is still important to actually stop a servicemember and say thanks - it will catch them unprepared! How we support them is in our daily lives, as many have stated. Standing up for them in conversations - no the errors they are caught up in are not their "fault", but they are doing their duty to defend our nation in their capacity. Sending care packages is a great way to show support. Also, letters to the troops is an amazing way to say thanks. I've answered many myself, from Elementary students to people my age or older. Another way is to try to understand what they are actually going through. Visiting our wounded troops in hospitals, showing your support when they arrive back from battle zones, even simply flying a flag. Stop and talk with a servicemember and try to understand their situations, the sacrifices they've lived through and given. Many have lost close friends in the fight and have a hard time dealing with the loss. Even someone to just listen is desperately needed. If you know someone who has decided to serve and will be deploying overseas, keep in touch with them the whole time they're gone - it means the world while someone's there, gives us the reason to fight. Mostly, try to stand in the troops shoes if you haven't actually been there and if you have been there (or are there now feeleja - THANKS!) don't be afraid to share your experiences so other people can understand. This situation can get muddled with all the politics and we need to remember every fallen soldier we've lost, pray for everyone deployed or family member left behind, and cheer the safe return of all those who do come home. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago Thanks, Leo. I want ot thank everyone for all that they've done. Out of all the discussions here, this is my favorite. Just remember that you are in my prayers everyday. God bless you. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago I just want to let you know on Marion Square in Charleston, SC that a bunch of us from different churches pray for those in the armed services for your safety every Thursday. We also pray for America and Israel. But there is not one Thursday, no matter what kind of weather, barring storms, we pray. God bless you. Thank you for doing what you are doing or have done. |
| back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago 49 days and counting till i come home from IRAQ !!!!! |
|
back to top |
| Posted about 1 month ago feeleja- we'll count with you If you're gonna be a bear....be a grizzly... |

I couldn't agree more and I love the Steven Curtis Chapman song, it is so appropriate. I agree with the posts above, especially what peacebe just mentioned that reminds us all that what we fight for is not just the cause we are in the middle of - often defending someone elses back door - but also for our families back home. To ensure that we are standing on our own back door in a firefight.